5 Tips to Bring First-Time Customers Back

You’re fine-tuning your social media campaign constantly. Cost per acquisition is down and conversion rates are up. Getting that first order is key – but what are you doing to turn that single order into a lifetime customer?

Here are 5 tips to bring first-time customers back for more.

1. Include a thank you note.

Tell customers that you appreciate their business. But if you’re going to make the effort, make it count with a little style and class.  Order stationery with your logo and handwrite the note. If your order volume is too high to warrant hand-written notes, use a hand-writing font and have it printed on uncoated stock to give it that personalized touch.


2. Step up your shipping game with packaging that customers remember.

Cheap and generic polybags and bubble mailers may save you a few pennies, but do nothing to make your brand memorable. High-quality packages reflect the quality of your products and show your customers you care about all the little details.

3. Use a rubber stamp or custom stickers.

If you want your customers to come back for more but you can’t afford custom packaging, using a rubber stamp or custom stickers on your packages can be a cheaper alternative to help you re-enforce your brand message.


4. Schedule automated email follow up.  

If you’re on Shopify you can automate email follow up with a MailChimp.  Send a follow-up email a week after your customer receives their order to ensure they are happy. Follow it up with a 30-day note.  If they don’t place a second order within 90 days, send a discount code to win them back.

5. Use discount codes to keep them coming back

Let’s face it, landing new accounts is costly. It is a lot less expensive to retain repeat customers with enticing promotions. Offer discount codes like:

  • “Flash sale – take 20% off orders placed today”
  • “Take 20% off on orders placed this month”
  • “Buy one, get one free”
  • “Order before 2:00 today and we will include a free gift”

Looking for affordable, high-quality e-commerce products packaging solutions? Best Mailer has the perfect selection of mailers in all the standard sizes you need.

Sign Up for Exclusive Offers

Join our email list for promotions, special offers and tips on how to cut your packaging costs.

Contact us

44 South Bayles Ave., Ste. 205
Port Washington, NY 11050

Follow us

Copyright © 2020 Conformer Products, Inc.. All rights reserved. CONFORMER® is a registered trademark of Conformer Products, Inc.
U.S. Pat. Nos.: 8,162,204 : 8,215,537 : 8,684,259 : 8,215,619 : 8,215,345 : 9,352,879. Canadian Pat. Nos. 2,418,571: 2,554,473 : 2,641,639. Other Patents Pending.

Your Cart
Ready to Ship More For Less?
Free "Complete Guide to eCommerce Packaging"

Sign up for our email list and receive your free ebook.

Hello, Neighbor!

Just note that we can only send large orders to Canada. To get accurate shipping rates, please fill out a custom request or eh-mail us at